Seasons Greetings
    

Flash News: Elon Musk mocks Biden for ignoring his company's historic space flight     - | -     COVID creates shortages of an array of U.S. medical supplies     - | -     FBI searches family home of fiancé Brian Laundrie after her likely remains were found #vanlife     - | -     The Biden cat's arrival to the White House has been delayed     - | -     Top U.S. General confirms Chinese, nuclear meetings but denies anti-Trump Plot      - | -     Russia still largest driver of disinformation on social media, Facebook report finds      - | -     Human remains found inside 500-pound alligator. How common are alligator attacks?      - | -     'New' Van Gogh drawing to go on display in Amsterdam museum      - | -     1 in every 500 US residents have died of Covid-19      - | -     Facebook draws lawmaker scrutiny over Instagram's impact on teens      - | -     Donald Trump's mental health becomes an issue again      - | -     Pakistan's Imran Khan says world should give Taliban 'time' on human rights but fears 'chaos' without aid      - | -     COVID-Sniffing dogs at miami airport have 99 percent accuracy at detecting infections      - | -     Biden vaccine plan hinges on rarely used rule, inviting legal challenges      - | -     New York city schools reopen to a mixture of fear and relief      - | -     U.S. COVID deaths highest since march, with Mississippi hit hardest      - | -     FBI releases newly declassified document on Saudi government's role in 9/11 attacks      - | -     Former Navy Commander Sentenced to Life in Prison for ‘Heinous’ Sexual Abuse and Child Pornography of a Family Member      - | -     Stop mounting your TVs above the fireplace: Why it's actually a terrible idea      - | -     What a CDC report says about vaccine effectiveness against the Delta variant      - | -     Pro-China misinformation operation attempting to exploit US Covid divisions      - | -     FBI releases new videos of suspect who planted pipe bombs outside RNC, DNC      - | -     Telemedicine abortion gets restricted in new executive order by South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem      - | -     Geronimo the alpaca, who UK health officials killed thinking he had bovine tuberculosis, might not have been sick      - | -     20 years on, 9/11 mastermind still awaits Guantanamo trial      - | -     Medicine is an imperfect science – but you can still trust its process      - | -     Trump's inner circle says after Afghan debacle he will run in 2024      - | -     J&J Shot study shows Covid infections halved in health workers      - | -     U.S. probing nearly 350 reports of oil spills in wake of Hurricane Ida      - | -     How to protect children under 12 from Covid-19, according to Fauci      - | -     TikTok, live streaming, and 'creator economy' quickly changing social apps landscape      - | -     Relatives of MH17 victims speak of trauma in court      - | -     Doctors in Covid-19 are 'surprised and disappointed' at new record hospitalizations      - | -     Singing star Sarah Harding dies at 39 after cancer fight      - | -     As Donald Trump makes noise about 2024, Melania Trump tries to stay out of the public eye      - | -     COVID vaccine boosters: When is it time for that extra shot? Here's what we know      - | -     At least 46 dead after flooding overwhelms NYC, Northeast      - | -     States that had some of the worst Covid-19 case rates in past week also reported the highest rates of new vaccinations      - | -     There's now an official Trump Card design, and getting one will cost you $45      - | -     British defense secretary suggests US is no longer a superpower after Afghanistan withdrawal      - | -     15M Covid vaccine doses have been wasted in the U.S. since March, new data shows      - | -     As Biden falters, a two-man race for the 2024 GOP nomination begins to take shape      - | -     What Hurricane Ida Means for Louisiana's COVID-19 Problem      - | -     Mu COVID variant, which scientists fear is resistant to vaccines, detected in 39 countries      - | -     Ida left more than 1 million without power for possibly weeks, and now comes the scorching heat      - | -     Florida woman hospitalized with Covid returns home to find husband dead of same disease      - | -     Radioactive snakes could help scientists track fallout from Fukushima Disaster      - | -     Covid third wave could peak between Oct-Nov in India; intensity expected to be 1/4 of second wave      - | -     One dead, New Orleans without power as Hurricane Ida slams Louisiana      - | -     Fear and anticipation on the streets of Kabul as Afghans adapt to Taliban rule      - | -     Florida radio host 'Mr. Anti-Vax' dies of COVID-19      - | -     This new antibody can stop all COVID-19 strains, including new variants, experts say      - | -     Biden on terror attack in Afghanistan, eviction moratorium blocked among others      - | -     Biden and Trump battle over what could have been in Afghanistan      - | -     Alone in the sky, pilot and fiancee save 17 in Tenn. flood      - | -     Experts find 231 million year-old fossil, ancestor to most reptiles      - | -     With more than 100,000 people in the hospital with Covid-19, this August is worse than last, expert says      - | -     Nearly two dozen San Diego, California, students and their families are stuck in Afghanistan      - | -     California looking to pay drug addicts to stay sober      - | -     Will an asteroid ever hit Earth? NASA scientist gives reassuring answer      - | -     Biden receives inconclusive intelligence report on covid origins      - | -     Why Biden will end the final mission in Afghanistan in just 7 days?      - | -     China wants families to have three children. But many women aren't convinced      - | -     Strange wasp nests glow neon green under UV light      - | -     Twin babies were 'swept away' in Tennessee floods that killed at least 22      - | -     Kathy Hochul sworn in as 1st female New York governor; Cuomo blasts state attorney general      - | -     Taliban takeover prompts fears of a resurgent al-Qaida      - | -     Kamala Harris condemns China, deflects from Kabul      - | -     At least 5 South Florida officers died from Covid-19 in one week      - | -     Heartburn drug may help doctors fight Covid-19      - | -     Dozens of US Air Force planes head to Kabul as 20,000 people remain stranded at airport      - | -     Astronauts and satellites watch Hurricane Henri from space as US Northeast braces for storm      - | -     US Covid-19 hospitalizations for children and adults under 50 reach their highest levels yet, CDC data shows      - | -     Afghans plead for faster US evacuation from Taliban rule      - | -     OPEC tells a weak, incompetent US president to drop dead      - | -     The Taliban want the world to think they've changed. Early signs suggest otherwise      - | -     Alabama has no available ICU beds while thousands of students quarantine in New Orleans and Florida      - | -     Seth Meyers Mocks George W. Bush’s Afghanistan Statement      - | -     Einstein's E=mc2 equation creates matter from light for first time      - | -     A complete “U turn” Taliban pledge 'totally different' moderate face as west continues evacuations      - | -     U.S. to Ship First of 500 Million Shots Pledged by Biden at G-7      - | -     Taliban announces 'amnesty,' urges women to join government      - | -     Chris Cuomo and his brother: 'I tried to do the right thing'      - | -     Why Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin is going to war with NASA and SpaceX      - | -     New York AG criticized for handling of Daniel Prude killing after Cuomo investigation      - | -     Biden administration taken to surprise by rapid Taliban seize in Afghanistan      - | -     Trump claims Afghanistan withdrawal would have been 'much more successful' if he were president.      - | -     Chaotic scenes at Kabul airport as Afghans and foreign nationals flee Taliban      - | -     Oregon Breaks COVID-19 hospitalization record three days in a Row     - | -     Should kids wear masks in school? These states have banned mandates despite experts’ pleas     - | -     Biden administration announces new two-month eviction moratorium     - | -     Death reported from Ebola-Like Marburg virus in West Africa     - | -     No lines at the buffet, daily onboard testing: Here's what it's like to take a cruise right now      - | -     Every two days, US wildfires are consuming an area the size of Washington, DC. And there's no let-up in sight      - | -     New York Times lawyer mistakenly sends private email on how to deal with the union to the union      - | -     Mumbai, India records first death from Delta Plus Covid variant      - | -     Officials still looking for parents of 337 separated children, court filing says      - | -     Missouri girl spent 5 days on oxygen, illustrating the growing problem of children not being vaccinated for Covid-19      - | -     Galaxy Z Flip 3 is $1,000 and no longer looks like a foldable drink coaster      - | -     India's Covid Situation Getting Worse, 'Daily Death Load      - | -     Pediatrician warns parents: Don't 'underestimate' the virus: Covid updates      - | -     Schools reopening without masking 'is a formula for disaster,' Louisiana children's hospital doctor says      - | -     NY Gov. Andrew Cuomo resigns after sexual harassment allegations, investigation      - | -     Female reporter being hunted by the Taliban tells her story      - | -     US turns to social media influencers to boost vaccine rates      - | -     US Covid-19 hospitalization and death rates double, 2 Texas ERs temporarily shut down      - | -     Biden’s radical remaking of America      - | -     Explainer: Beyond Delta, scientists are watching new coronavirus variants      - | -     Tens of thousands of vaccinated people may catch Covid-19. But the unvaccinated are 'the big highway of transmission,' experts say      - | -     Town burns to ashes in raging Northern California wildfire      - | -     Dr. Fauci Praises Trump for 'Wise Investment' in COVID-19 Vaccine Development      - | -     Gamma, delta, lambda – here’s your guide to the Greek alphabet of the COVID-19 variants      - | -     U.S. COVID-19 cases hit six-month high at over 100,000      - | -     Is Indian govt going back on vaccine policy by tapping into 25% jabs reserved for private hospitals?      - | -     Mark Levin says Biden should be removed from office      - | -     Delta plus: What we know about the latest coronavirus variant      - | -     Florida and Texas had one-third of all Covid-19 cases in past week, official says      - | -     Andrew Cuomo quizzed for 11 hours about sexual harassment and misconduct accusations      - | -     Tucker Carlson slams former President Obama over birthday bash      - | -     Afghans who risked lives to help American troops set to arrive in US      - | -     Are Covid boosters needed? Some nursing home residents to have immunity checked      - | -     How Biden’s sherpa, Steve Ricchetti, scored the big deal      - | -     'Frightening' Covid surge widens Japan's emergency      - | -     The US see rise in Covid cases; Delta variant feared as most contagious and dangerous strain      - | -     A man was charged with hate crimes for attacks on Muslims in New York City      - | -     Outrage grows after Deputies beat native American man, kill his dog      - | -     Beijing reports first Covid case in 179 days as alarm grows over Nanjing Delta cluster      - | -     Is Houston seeing a mirror image of last year's COVID summer surge?      - | -     Apple says chip shortage reaches iPhone, growth forecast slows      - | -     Two dead after leak at Texas chemical plant      - | -     Can Biden's plans manufacture more US factory jobs?      - | -     House begins Capitol attack inquiry as Republicans set to boycott proceedings      - | -     Barbara Boxer: Former California senator is a victim of assault and theft      - | -     The US could see 200,000 Covid-19 cases a day within the next six weeks: Former CDC director      - | -     Five die as Indian policemen fire at each other      - | -     Why India's outbreak is a threat to the world     - | -     Suspected smuggling boat tragedy in San Diego adds to Biden's migrant crisis woes     - | -     Maryland votes to nix state song, a Confederate call to arms     - | -     Kim Janey rewrites history, Boston's first Black and female mayor     - | -     Gunman kills 10 at Colorado supermarket in second US mass shooting in a week     - | -     Kamala Harris laughs when asked if she will visit the border raises sharp criticism online     - | -     Roger Stone under fresh scrutiny as Capitol attack investigation intensifies     - | -     Vaccines will likely not be mandatory for teachers: Biden’s Education Secretary     - | -     Fauci warns about potential for an oncoming resurgence of virus if restrictions eased     - | -     Biden plug relief to Americans, celebrates 'transformational' victory on COVID-19 relief     - | -     LA Schools to Reopen in mid-April & NY City will open high schools next week     - | -     Women are tired of explaining to men like Andrew Cuomo why sexual harassment is wrong     - | -     Biden signs orders on gender equity, nominates two women to be four-star commanders     - | -     Nation takes baby steps to normality after year in lockdown; "The virus isn't going to go away," says Harvard epidemiologist     - | -     Rumours of vaccine site giving jabs to anyone because of low demand. Hundreds lined up     - | -     Vaccine supply will "dramatically" increase in weeks ahead: Fauci     - | -     Biden calls it "Neanderthal thinking" slams Texas and Mississippi's decisions to lift COVID-19 mask mandates     - | -     This Is What GOP Feared. Now that Trump Has Governed with Executive Orders, Dems Plan to Do Same      - | -     Man Throwing 'Incendiary Devices' at ICE Detention Center Is Killed in Attack      - | -     Mueller Hearing Pushed Back a Week to Allow More Time for Him to Answer Questions      - | -     Trump Tells 4 Congresswomen of Color to 'Go Back' to 'Crime-Infested' Countries They Came From      - | -     GOP Congressman Invokes 'The Deep State'

Features & Columns

Medicine is an imperfect science – but you can still trust its process

viewsViews 172

Medicine is an imperfect science – but you can still trust its process

2021-09-08 02:21:23

By K. Shalini  Image Source: Screen Shot

As an intensive care physician in Southern California who endured the onslaught of COVID-19 in 2020, it has been deeply disheartening to experience chillingly familiar scenes all over again. The ICUs in the University of California San Diego Health hospital network where I work are again overflowing – especially with patients who need ventilators. Families peer through tinted hospital windows for glimpses of loved ones. And hospital administrators scramble to keep up with necessary staffing and beds to accommodate the influx of patients.

What is so vexing is that COVID-19 is still the culprit, despite the availability of highly effective vaccines that slashed U.S. COVID-19 daily case numbers and hospitalizations within months. The vaccines also allowed economies to begin to recover and provided a way for people to experience some sense of normalcy again.

In early spring, the efficacy of the vaccine engendered hope that herd immunity – in which infectious viral spread is prevented through a high proportion of the population’s being immune to the disease – could be within reach in months. Instead, pandemic panic is again suffocating us, largely because a large part of the public still shuns vaccination – with only 62% of the eligible U.S. population fully vaccinated as of early September 2021.

I wanted an answer to the obvious question: Why?

So I turned to my patients for answers. At the bedside in their hospital rooms, I first asked about how they were feeling and performed detailed exams before addressing the elephant in the room. “Did you receive the COVID-19 vaccine?” And if not, I gently asked, “Did you have a specific reason you could share with me, so I can understand better?”

Somewhat surprisingly, patients candidly told me their reasons for avoiding the vaccine.

A common response I heard was that it was simply inconvenient. “I was too lazy and I didn’t get around to it,” some admitted, looking away sheepishly as they did so. Curiously, they did not consider the myriad “inconveniences” of becoming infected, such as medical complications – including death – and associated costs for treatment, lost work, dependence on others for basic necessities such as child care, the risk of infecting family members, the potential for developing long-haul COVID-19 and more.

Others expressed a fervid distrust of vaccine-testing methods, stating that people had been “guinea pigs in past vaccine experiments that later caused autism.” Yet more than 25 studies in the past 20-odd years have disproved any causal link between vaccines and autism.

Some felt that the forceful public messaging to get vaccinated belied true motivations of the authorities, adding: “I mean, why are they pushing this so hard? Something must be wrong with it.” Yet few question the strong public health stance on healthy eating practices and exercise, or wearing seat belts while driving.

Still others feared the possibility of life-threatening side effects: “Thousands had heart attacks from the vaccine – it’s all on the CDC website,” they told me. So I took a close look at the CDC website to understand their claims better.

Reports of heart inflammation occurred in 699 cases out of 177 million vaccinated people, or 0.0004%, with causal links to the vaccines still being investigated. Development of blood clots causally associated with the Johnson & Johnson vaccine are also extremely rare, occurring in 28 cases out of 8.73 million doses given as of May 7, 2021 – a rate of 0.0003%. This extremely low risk of blood clots is still significantly lower than the risk of blood clots from an actual COVID-19 infection.

Medicine as art and imperfect science

In some cases, political affiliation can partially explain vaccine antipathy. But my patients’ responses highlighted two other themes to me.

First, people often forget that medicine is an art based on applied science, not a deductive science based on irrefutable forces in nature like gravity. Patients and families often ask me in the ICU to predict what will happen to loved ones unequivocally, only to be disappointed when I avoid speaking in certainties.

Once viewed as omniscient authorities, doctors now openly acknowledge that limitations of medical data require scrutiny and careful application to particular circumstances. COVID-19 has reinforced our appreciation that there are no perfect cures or 100% guarantees of success. Rather, medicine is governed by what is probable. What are the chances I still may have cancer if the test result returns negative? Am I more or less likely to survive pneumonia by taking this specific antibiotic?

Doctors must then engage in thoughtful analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of scientific methods and data to optimize and tailor our recommendations for individual patients – without the luxury of perfect or even complete datasets to rely on. The vaccine has clearly been shown – its rare side effects notwithstanding – to provide an overwhelmingly high likelihood of benefit over potential risks to almost all individuals. This includes people who have been previously infected with COVID-19. Yet the unvaccinated continue to fixate on rare side effects to justify skipping the shot.

Vaccines are medicines too

Many of my patients also seem to view vaccines and other public health-based recommendations like offers to buy a used car – with skepticism and independence, threatening to walk away at any moment. Doing one’s part to stop the spread of disease is a culturally nuanced civic virtue, like safe driving, which transcends absolute autonomy. In the U.S., most drivers willingly do not drive while intoxicated, cross lanes without warning or block other cars that are trying to merge. These are norms that make driving in the U.S. relatively efficient, safe and even pleasant compared with some other countries.

The path to herd immunity, like highway safety, requires majority participation without immediate guarantees of complete personal freedom. Vaccines succeed not because they are 100% risk-free to the individual but because collective efforts focus on achieving the common good.

Oddly, at the same time that my patients rejected the vaccine, they showed strong interest in receiving other types of medicine “shots” like monoclonal antibodies – which mimic natural antibodies – or anti-inflammatory medications. While some of these treatments have demonstrated benefits in certain situations – others have not. And some present the risk of very serious harm.

I reminded my patients that the COVID-19 vaccine stimulates a person’s own immune system to make antibodies that can neutralize the virus and that surpass the capabilities of commercially created antibody formulations. So the vaccines help prevent infection and development of serious illness from COVID-19 in the first place. People who experience the rare breakthrough infections following vaccination generally have a shorter and milder course of COVID-19 infection and are far less likely to end up hospitalized than those who are unvaccinated. Vaccines also confer longer-term protection, whereas the other medications are used reactively – when a serious infection has already begun – and those medications have shorter-term results.

How past vaccination efforts succeeded

In the past, many vaccines that successfully vanquished societal outbreaks of polio, measles and mumps are now routinely administered in childhood with minimal objection, despite the fact that there is no such thing as zero risk.

As I continue to have conversations with patients who suffer greatly from COVID-19 illness as a direct consequence of having avoided the vaccine, my own pain – for being an ineffective healer and witness to such loss – is inexorable. Overcoming this fourth wave of COVID-19 still feels out of reach until our vaccination efforts can somehow better emphasize the effectiveness of vaccines, even when scientifically imperfect, and prioritize civic health care responsibilities over pure autonomy. If not, I fear that our battle against COVID-19 will rage on.

Post Your Comment




Most Recent News

La Liga: Madrid Boss Ancelotti Empathizes With Rival Koeman's Situation at Barcelona

21 September, 2021

  Madrid boss Ancelotti empathises with Koeman's situation at Barcelona  ...More

Golf: Jordan Spieth Hoping 'Youth and Fire' Can Spark Team USA to Ryder Cup Glory

21 September, 2021

  Spieth hoping 'youth and fire' can spark Team USA to Ryder Cup glory  ...More

Boxing: Jojo Diaz Asks Who Wants to Fight? Ryan Garica or Devin Haney?

21 September, 2021

  Jojo Diaz: Who wants to fight? Ryan Garica or Devin Haney?  ...More

Get Published

Want to publish your own articles?

Create an account, and submit your articles, photos and/or videos. They will be reviewed by our professional copy editors, and if it is approved, it will be published for all our readers to view.

 
 

MORE FOR YOU