Seasons Greetings

Flash News: Milkha Singh: India's legendary sprinter dies of Covid-19 complications at 91      - | -     Air Force is designing bird-like microdrones for warzone surveillance      - | -     Biden urges more Americans to get vaccinated but is silent on July 4 target      - | -     Fierce Capitol attacks on police in newly released videos      - | -     The sycophantic inner circle egging on Trump – and fueling his big lie      - | -     You probably need to thank a migrant worker for your daily milk      - | -     Giant Buddhist goddess in Japan gets face mask to pray for end of Covid-19      - | -     Satya Nadella's notable rise from a young engineer to Microsoft chairman      - | -     Google India announces $15 million grant to set up 80 oxygen plants     - | -     Inquiry into 'fake Covid tests' at Kumbh Mela     - | -     10,000 years of climate memory have been preserved in The oldest ice from The Alps     - | -     Nearly 900 New Yorkers administered with expired Covid-19 jabs     - | -     Once hardest hit, New York, California lifts most COVID-19 restrictions as vaccination rates top 70%      - | -     US surpasses 600,000 deaths from the coronavirus      - | -     Texas man arrested after allegedly dragging mom's ex behind truck and setting vehicle ablaze      - | -     China says nuclear fuel rods damaged, no radiation leak      - | -     Act of kindness: the Kashmiri man who is India’s biggest blood donor      - | -     Wooden satellite first of its kind aims to prove plywood can survive space      - | -     Biden says that America’s ‘back.’ One question lingers: For how long?      - | -     Donald Trump Jr. Slams 'Incompetent' Fauci, Claims He's 'Not a Scientist'      - | -     Head of 'world's largest family' dies in India      - | -     The evolution, how bad the COVID-19 variants can get?      - | -     Airplane uncovered at the bottom of a California lake likely to be from 1965 crash      - | -     US gun violence reaches 270 so far this year      - | -     Human smugglers with links to cartels operate on Facebook, a report alleges.      - | -     White rhino travels Taiwan to Japan looking for love      - | -     Extraordinary times, extraordinary measures': U.S. approach to vanquish pandemic      - | -     Colorado is smashing down barriers expands access to housing, jobs and state benefits to undocumented immigrants      - | -     India records more than 6,000 daily Covid deaths      - | -     Bitcoin to be official currency in El Salvador under three months      - | -     Reports of severe COVID or death after vaccination are rare in remote cases      - | -     Fauci sticks around lab leak theory and not changed mind, equates criticism with 'Attacks on Science'      - | -     No data Covid will seriously impact children in future waves: AIIMS Chief in India      - | -     How a blood test can tell if cancer treatment is working right away      - | -     Telegraph Fire, the ninth largest in Arizona history, reaches 76,260 acres; Mescal Fire 23% contained      - | -     Covid-19 variant 1st detected in India still a threat to US: Fauci      - | -     Death toll climbs to 63 after horrific collision of two trains in Pakistan      - | -     Biden admin threatens to sue Texas over migrant facility plans      - | -     When your biological father is your mother's fertility doctor: 'fertility fraud'      - | -     US seizes $2.3 million in bitcoin paid to Colonial Pipeline hackers      - | -     Sharks almost wiped out 19 million years ago, and scientists don't know why     - | -     Trump's grievances cloud Republican agenda heading into 2022     - | -     Unexplained brain syndrome grips Canada, 48 people affected     - | -     Vaccination rates drop, imperilling Biden’s July Fourth goal     - | -     "Hugely Discriminatory": India Opposes Vaccine Passports at G7 Meet     - | -     Fireball meteor over Brazil may have come from another solar system     - | -     U.S. Justice Dept got gag order on NY Times execs in fight over email logs - NYT     - | -     The slowing Covid-19 vaccination rate is worrying experts. Here's what some states are doing to change the trend     - | -     ‘Lazy’ AI: Researchers find that technology can misdiagnose COVID-19 by taking shortcuts     - | -     9-year-old driver and younger sister unharmed after crashing into semi-truck     - | -     Biden widens list of Chinese firms off-limits for investment     - | -     Fauci calls on China to release medical records of Wuhan lab workers; Chinese scientists rejects lab leak hypothesis     - | -     Supreme Court in India criticizes its government over Covid-19 vaccination drive     - | -      New York's Cuomo seeks state police help to probe war memorial vandalism     - | -     Largest meat producer getting back online after cyberattack     - | -     “Get a shot and have a beer, celebrate the independence from the virus”: Biden's new Covid strategy woos vaccine skeptics     - | -     China reports first known human case of H10N3 bird flu     - | -     Arizona plans to use hydrogen cyanide to execute prisoners – a lethal gas the Nazis used at Auschwitz     - | -     The Trump Organization wants to sell its D.C. hotel yet again.     - | -     Hiker dies after falling 500 feet from the summit of Mount Russell, Sequoia National Park     - | -     The Coronavirus variant found in India to be called 'Delta' in new WHO system     - | -     Four more Oath Keepers accused in alleged Capitol riot conspiracy     - | -     A 7-year-old boy welcomed a hero, swam for an hour to get help for his dad and sister stranded in a river     - | -     Vaccinated Americans are celebrating the 1st big holiday safely without masks. But for some, returning to normal is not so easy      - | -     Teenager severely burned imitating TikTok video, family says     - | -     Texas Democrats stage walkout to block passage of sweeping election overhaul package     - | -     Charge your phone in just 8 minutes? Xiaomi announces insanely fast 200W wired charging     - | -     Johnson & Johnson asks high court to void $2B talc verdict in favor of women who developed ovarian cancer     - | -     Senate eyes R&D bill to counter China, bolster manufacturing     - | -     How to combat misinformation around 5G     - | -     Microblogging platform Twitter fears for freedom of expression in India     - | -     COVID-19 cases spiking again at some ICE detention centers many blames Biden administration     - | -     Cyclone leaves coastal villages in eastern India, Bangladesh cut off by tidal surges      - | -     Giant tortoise thought extinct 100 years ago is living in Galapagos, Ecuador says      - | -     Biden administration backs Alaska oil project approved under Trump      - | -     Biden orders more intel investigation of COVID-19 origin – A trail that can lead to Chinese laboratory      - | -     WhatsApp sues India govt, says new rules mean end to privacy      - | -     39-year-old found dead inside Spanish dinosaur statue     - | -     Top U.S. health official calls for follow-up investigation into pandemic’s origins     - | -     COVID-19 vaccination could get you free beer, doughnuts and $1 million     - | -     Why India's outbreak is a threat to the world     - | -     Suspected smuggling boat tragedy in San Diego adds to Biden's migrant crisis woes     - | -     Maryland votes to nix state song, a Confederate call to arms     - | -     Kim Janey rewrites history, Boston's first Black and female mayor     - | -     Gunman kills 10 at Colorado supermarket in second US mass shooting in a week     - | -     Kamala Harris laughs when asked if she will visit the border raises sharp criticism online     - | -     Roger Stone under fresh scrutiny as Capitol attack investigation intensifies     - | -     Vaccines will likely not be mandatory for teachers: Biden’s Education Secretary     - | -     Fauci warns about potential for an oncoming resurgence of virus if restrictions eased     - | -     Biden plug relief to Americans, celebrates 'transformational' victory on COVID-19 relief     - | -     LA Schools to Reopen in mid-April & NY City will open high schools next week     - | -     Women are tired of explaining to men like Andrew Cuomo why sexual harassment is wrong     - | -     Biden signs orders on gender equity, nominates two women to be four-star commanders     - | -     Nation takes baby steps to normality after year in lockdown; "The virus isn't going to go away," says Harvard epidemiologist     - | -     Rumours of vaccine site giving jabs to anyone because of low demand. Hundreds lined up     - | -     Vaccine supply will "dramatically" increase in weeks ahead: Fauci     - | -     Biden calls it "Neanderthal thinking" slams Texas and Mississippi's decisions to lift COVID-19 mask mandates     - | -     This Is What GOP Feared. Now that Trump Has Governed with Executive Orders, Dems Plan to Do Same      - | -     Man Throwing 'Incendiary Devices' at ICE Detention Center Is Killed in Attack      - | -     Mueller Hearing Pushed Back a Week to Allow More Time for Him to Answer Questions      - | -     Trump Tells 4 Congresswomen of Color to 'Go Back' to 'Crime-Infested' Countries They Came From      - | -     GOP Congressman Invokes 'The Deep State'

Business & Technology

NASA photos are not evidence of fungus growing on Mars

viewsViews 352

NASA photos are not evidence of fungus growing on Mars

2021-05-07 06:33:47

By Dwaipayan

NASA's Perseverance rover is up there searching for life and the agency's Mars helicopter, Ingenuity, is pulling off daring aerial feats. But on Wednesday, Mars appeared in the news for all the wrong reasons. According to websites like the Daily Mail, scientists were making a wild claim: Fungi was alive and well on the red planet.

The "mushrooms on Mars and fungi on Venus" theory is a worn out, debunked idea that appears like clockwork, about once a year. The headlines certainly are interesting imagine if we found fungi on Mars or Venus! It would literally rewrite our ideas about life in the cosmos but the articles rarely interrogate the scientific evidence for the wild claims.

Part of me wants to let it slide because in some cases any publicity really is good publicity, but this is bad science and some websites have erroneously headlined articles with "Scientists Found Evidence of Fungus Growing on Mars" when that is simply not the case.

The "Space Tiger King"

At the center, or sometimes just off to the side, of these outlandish claims is a man named Rhawn Gabriel Joseph.

According to his webpage "," Joseph is a lapsed neuroscientist who made major contributions to the field of neuroplasticity in the 1970s. Joseph has, for over a decade, published claims about life on other planets on his website and in pseudo-scientific journals he oversees.

His assertions sometimes make it to the big leagues and spill over into the press but, for the most part, they haven't landed in legitimate scientific journals or been scrutinized by other experts in space science.

Until 2019, when Joseph's claims really hit the big leagues. In November 2019, Joseph got a piece through peer review and into the journal Astrophysics & Space Science. Last June, I published a piece on Joseph and these claims, which eventually led to the journal retracting Joseph's article claiming "the article proffers insufficient critical assessment of the material presented and literature cited, and fails to provide a solid underpinning for the speculative statements made in the article which, in their view, invalidates the conclusions drawn."

But on Wednesday, Joseph's claims made it into another journal, known as Advances in Microbiology.

NASA Perseverance rover explores the wilds of Mars

NASA started a new chapter in its space exploration history book with the safe landing of the Perseverance rover on Mars on Feb. 18. This stunning image shows the rover as it was lowered to the surface using what's called a "sky crane" maneuver.This could very well become an iconic image when it comes to humanity's efforts to investigate our solar system. Perseverance is on a mission to seek out signs of ancient microbial life, collect samples and deploy a tiny helicopter named Ingenuity.

NASA started a new chapter in its space exploration history book with the safe landing of the Perseverance rover on Mars on Feb. 18. This stunning image shows the rover as it was lowered to the surface using what's called a "sky crane" maneuver.This could very well become an iconic image when it comes to humanity's efforts to investigate our solar system. Perseverance is on a mission to seek out signs of ancient microbial life, collect samples and deploy a tiny helicopter named Ingenuity.

Day of the truffles

Advances in Microbiology is a relatively obscure journal published by Scientific Research Publishing (SCIRP), which is headquartered in China and has previously been caught out for republishing scientific articles, according to Nature. It has been accused of being a predatory publisher, charging scientists fees to be published in its journals without checking the quality of the submitted papers, in the past.

The new paper, dubbed "Fungi on Mars? Evidence of Growth and Behavior From Sequential Images" and available on ResearchGate rehashes some of the old arguments for life on Mars, using inaccurate methodology to draw its conclusions. For the most part, Joseph and his co-authors use images obtained by NASA rovers and draw red lines and arrows to point out features they believe correspond to fungal growth.

"Claiming that mushrooms are sprouting all over Mars is an extraordinary claim that requires better evidence than an analysis of photographic morphology by a known crank who has claimed, on the basis of the same kind of analysis, that he has seen fields of skulls on Mars," says Paul Myers, a developmental biologist at the University of Minnesota, Morris, who has followed Joseph's work in the past.

One experiment, performed by the authors, is to analyze the size and movement of "spherical specimens" in the paper. It routinely references previous work by Joseph as evidence for its conclusions. The team suggests it "would be surprising" if there were no life on Mars -- but this is not true. We have mountains of data showing the conditions of Mars are not conducive to life as we know it. Could fungi get around these conditions? Perhaps, but the evidence for that is thin.

After being alerted to the new paper on Wednesday, I sent emails to the associate editors-in-chief of Advances in Microbiology,  asking for clarification around the peer review process. They have not responded to requests for comment.

I also emailed members of the editorial board listed on SCIRP's website, including Jian Li, a microbiologist at Monash University in Australia. He says he has not been on the journal's editorial board "for at least five to six years" and has not handled any of the papers in the journal.

Bad science

One of the bigger problems in publishing about Joseph's claims is allowing bad science to make its way to the public.

The pandemic has shown us misinformation can be harmful, eroding the confidence in science, researchers and institutes. We've seen, time and again, how erroneous reports can go viral and then later used to suggest scientists are backflipping on previous claims. To be clear, there's no backflip here. The majority of scientists agree the conditions at Mars' surface are not great for fungi to flourish.

"All available evidence suggests the surface of Mars is not hospitable to life," says Brendan Burns, an astrobiologist from the University of New South Wales in Australia.

When publications promote the unscientific "mushrooms on Mars" theory without critique, it can be damaging for scientists like Burns and organizations like NASA, who are attempting to find legitimate signs of life on other planets in the cosmos.

If we were to find life elsewhere in the solar system, it wouldn't first appear in the Advances in Microbiology journal. Readers should remain skeptical of any fungi claims they see -- especially those which are promulgated by a single group of scientists.

And look, I'm totally happy to be wrong here. If it turns out this is fungus on Mars, I will be the first to say "we stuffed up."

I'm hopeful NASA's Perseverance rover, which is currently rolling along the plains of an ancient Martian lakebed, might be able to find the first signs life once existed on the red planet. China's soon-to-be-delivered rover, Zhurong, could also help understand whether Mars harbored alien life forms. We'll have to wait and see.

Post Your Comment

Most Recent News

Euro 2020: Bottled It! Ronaldo Sparks Coca-Cola Conundrum

19 June, 2021

  Bottled it! Ronaldo sparks Coca-Cola conundrum  ...More

Euro 2020: Portugal v Germany Match Preview

19 June, 2021

  Portugal v Germany match preview  ...More

Football: NFL and Black College Football Hall of Fame Host Inaugural General Manager Forum and 4th Quarterback Coaching Summit

19 June, 2021

  -posted by Daniel Mogollon, Staff Writer; Image: Baltimore Ravens executive vice president Ozzie Newsome’s with 2018 first-round pick Lamar Jackson. (Image Source: Patrick......More

Get Published

Want to publish your own articles?

Create an account, and submit your articles, photos and/or videos. They will be reviewed by our professional copy editors, and if it is approved, it will be published for all our readers to view.