Site Search
Google Search
search button
Breaking News: Trump Cancels Planned Summit with Kim Jong Un of North Korea After Nuclear Test Site Is Closed     - | -     What Did Michael Flynn Jr. Mean When He Tweeted 'You're All Going Down?'     - | -     Despite Trump Blaming Obama for Campaign Surveillance, Senate Decides Obama Too Slow Regarding Russian Meddling      - | -     Cohen Was 'Paid by Ukraine' to Arrange Conversations with White House     - | -     Cohen's Business Partner Pleads Guilty in Deal That Requires Him to Cooperate in Ongoing Investigations      - | -     GOP Congressman Invokes 'The Deep State'
loading
Your Opinion
Get Alerts

viewsViews 204
In 1998 Giuliani Argued the President Could Be Subpoenaed; 20 Years Later Singing Different Tune 10 May 2018 10:28 PM EST

By Laura Tucker, Staff writer; Image: Rudy Giuliani (Image Source: Gage Skidmore via Wikimedia Commons)

 

Rudy Giuliani has been all over the news this past week supporting his new client, Donald Trump. After it was suggested Special Counsel Robert Mueller might subpoena him, Giuliani indicated they don't have to comply. A 20-year-old interview says he was once singing a different tune.

At a meeting in March Trump's attorneys stated he wasn't obligated to speak with Mueller's investigators regarding the possible collusion between his campaign and Russia to influence the campaign. Mueller responded by suggesting he could subpoena the president to appear before a grand jury, 

"We don't have to," Giuliani said recently. "He's the president of the United States. We can assert the same privileges other presidents have."

But in 1998, he felt a lot differently when Bill Clinton was the subject being questioned and not Trump.

In an interview with Charlie Rose, Giuliani said, "You gotta do it. I mean, you don't have a choice."

Rose wondered what would happen if the president refused, and Giuliani replied, "Then there is a procedure for handling that. You go before a judge, and a judge decides whether or not he has a recognizable exemption or privilege from testifying. And if a judge decides that he doesn't, you have to testify. You don't have a choice about it."

The former New York mayor also contended that the Watergate case that led to Richard Nixon resigning "resolved the fact that the president is not above the law, is not able to avoid subpoenas." 

He felt a president has the right to visit a judge to ensure the proceeding is improper. "And, if a judge agrees that, fine," he said. "But if a judge doesn't, then you have to testify."

Giuliani stated back then in 1998 that with regards to criminal law, the president should be treated the same as any other citizen.

And while in 2018 Trump has suggested the investigation surrounding him is hurting the country, 20 years ago Giuliani thought the U.S. could handle it. "The wisdom of the American public may be far greater than we realize," he said then.

Bill Clinton was the first sitting president to be subpoenaed to testify before a federal grand jury. This was in regards to whether he had a sexual relationship with White House intern Monica Lewinsky and then lied about it under oath. 

Clinton went on to appear in front of the grand jury, with independent counsel Kenneth Starr presenting evidence that he'd committed perjury and obstruction of justice. Clinton was impeached by the House, while the Senate acquitted him on both charges.

The question remains on whether Giuliani has changed his mind in 20 years, whether he is simply looking at this as a partisan matter, or whether he is simply doing his job and defending his client.

Just as Giuliani is waffling with his statements regarding Trump, if you go back 20 years, he is still waffling.

Comments
down_strip
2 May, 2018
What to Expect from Gun-Control Advocates During NRA Convention

By Laura Tucker, Staff writer; Image: Wayne LaPierre (Image Source: Michael Vadon)   The National Rifle Association is gearing up for their national convention this week, and it happens to come at a very contentious time for them. Not only are they facing extreme pressure over mass shootings, but there is also a belief that they have received... Read more

down_strip
1 May, 2018
Climate Change Group To Carve Trump's Face In Glacier

A Finnish climate group is attempting to raise half a million dollars in order to carve President Donald Trump's face into a glacier.The glacial art project, by the Finland-based group Melting Ice, has been coined "Project Trumpmore."If the group is able to successfully raise the funds to complete this project, they'll document the construction and broadcast... Read more

down_strip
21 April, 2018
The Million Dollar Question, Will The President Fire Mueller

In Washington lawmakers have expressed great concern that President Donald Trump may try to fire Robert Mueller, the special counsel assigned to investigating possible collusion and wrongdoing between the Trump Presidential campaign and Russia. Trump has already fired the former FBI director James Comey which raises concern for the future of Mueller.... Read more

down_strip
3 April, 2018
Sean Hannity Jumps into Roseanne Barr's Fight with Journalist Over Trump Content in Sitcom

by Laura Tucker, Staff Writer; Image: Roseanne Barr (Image Source: Stand-Up Sucks LLC via Wikimedia Commons)   Roseanne Barr picked up an ally that a few years ago would have seemed unlikely. But after she went public as a Trump supporter and now is basing the reboot of her sitcom on the same, she's picked up the support of Sean Hannity who defended... Read more

down_strip
8 December, 2017
DJ Who Groped Taylor Swift Sends $1 Judgment in Sacajawea Coin

-by Laura Tucker, Staff Writer; Image: Taylor Swift's cover for Reputation (Image Source: Instagram) A few months before the sexual misconduct accusations blew up around much of Hollywood, Taylor Swift won a court case against a man who had groped her in a photo. The singer posed for a photo with the DJ, David Mueller, and his girlfriend, and after... Read more

down_strip
Prev
1 of 418 pages
FREE
amny-app AllMediaNY AllMediaNY AllMedaiNY
allmediany market place
Most Recent Articles
Paramount Pull Transformers 6 From Schedule
Paramount Pull Transformers 6 From Schedule
24 May, 2018

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/vgPRBHfsugc" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; encrypted-media" allowfullscreen></iframe>More

Trevor Noah Made Secret Cameo In Blank Panther
Trevor Noah Made Secret Cameo In Blank Panther
24 May, 2018

Trevor Noah has a role in Black Panther but nobody knew. The Daily Show host had an important cameo that most of us probably missed. Trevor voiced Groit the AI within the Wakandan Ship that was flown...More

Release Date Announced For Elton John Biopic 'Rocketman'
Release Date Announced For Elton John Biopic 'Rocketman'
24 May, 2018

Release Date Announced For Elton John Biopic 'Rocketman'    More