Site Search
Google Search
Breaking News: Escaped N.Y. Prisoner Richard Matt Shot Dead; David Sweat Still On the Run     - | -     Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Marriage Equality for All 50 States
Editorials
Get Alerts

29 Jun 2015 10:27 PM EST

- by Jorge Vargas, Editor


A lot of people are very excited about the Supreme Court's decision to approve gay marriage across the United States. 

A lot of people are not.

Among that second group?

Four Supreme Court justices, including Justice Antonin Scalia, who wrote a scathing and arguably incomprehensible dissent against his colleagues' majority decision. Scalia accused the court of being elitist and of not representing the United States.

All in all, troubling accusations to be made by a member of the highest court in a country with a legal system that has been the model of countless other legal systems around the world.

More troubling is the fact that he's right.

The Supreme Court has become elitist and it does not represent the American people. The American people would not have approved the legalization of big corporate donations for politicians in unlimited amounts. Most people would call that unethical, and in many other countries, it would be corruption.

Most people would also not agree with the extremist arguments often put forward by justices who are either too far to the right or left. 

And the growing political importance of the Supreme Court has made it an elitist institution. 

All of this makes one wonder if, perhaps, it's time to change the Supreme Court. Maybe it's time for the Supreme Court justices to not serve for life or until retirement. Maybe having them serve appointed terms will make them less all-powerful and make the justices less entrenched in their political views. 

It's a tough argument but it's one that bears mentioning now that we're confronted with the aggressiveness shown by Scalia, and with the fact that the justices are making decisions that affect the lives on hundreds of millions of people. 

Or, maybe, instead of presidential appointment, Supreme Court justices can be appointed by region (a representative from the northeast, another from the Pacific coast, etc.). 

Maybe that's what Scalia is getting at when he calls out the court for being elitist and not representative of the United States. 

Or, maybe, he's just blowing smoke, recognizing a lost cause for what it is and hoping to give off the impression of going down swinging.

Comments
29 June, 2015
'Touch Me!' Says an HIV-positive Man

An HIV-positive Finnish man wants to challenge people with a simple request — reaching out and touching him.For a social experiment, a man named Janne stands in a busy square with a sign on either side of him reading "I am HIV-positive — touch me!" While some walk away in disapproval or simply choose not to go up to Janne, others go up to him and give... Read more

24 June, 2015
Fifty Shades Rewrite Breaks Sales Record

EL James' new Fifty Shades of Grey spin-off novel has broken the first week UK sales record for adult books.Grey sold 647,401 copies in its first three days, beating record holder Dan Brown's The Lost Symbol, which sold 551,000 copies in five days in 2009.The book tells the same Fifty Shades story but from the perspective of male protagonist Christian... Read more

18 June, 2015
New 'Fifty Shades of Grey' Book to Hit Stores on Thursday

E.L. James, the British author of the hugely successful "Fifty Shades of Grey" erotic novels, is celebrating the fictional birthday of her famous male character on Thursday with the release of her new book, "Grey," which looks set to be an instant bestseller. Publisher Vintage Books said demand for the novel, told from the viewpoint of business tycoon... Read more

10 June, 2015
Sassy Little Dancer Girl Slays Aretha Franklin's "Respect"

A little girl tap danced flawlessly to Aretha Franklin's "Respect" in a recital over the weekend, drawing widespread attention across social media. A mom from Raleigh, North Carolina posted a video of her six-year-old daughter's dance recital and it quickly became an Internet sensation, racking up over 22 million views since Sunday. Why did it go viral?... Read more

10 June, 2015
Man Gives Mouth-To-Mouth To Endangered Turtle, Saves Life

A contestant on " The Island with Bear Grylls " set aside his own survival instincts to lock lips with an endangered sea turtle to bring it back from the dead. On Monday night's episode, hungry contestants accidentally trapped the turtle in one of their fishing nets, and found it drowning. Normally on a 'Bear Grylls' show, wildlife be damned when it comes... Read more

Prev
1 of 30 pages
FREE
AllMediaNY AllMediaNY AllMedaiNY
allmediany market place
Most Recent Articles
‘Pitch Perfect’ Star Drops Freestye About His Dog’s Crap
‘Pitch Perfect’ Star Drops Freestye About His Dog’s Crap
2 July, 2015

Score one for the Treblemakers! " Pitch Perfect " star Utkarsh Ambudkar ripped a freestyle rap after being inspired by his dog. After seeing his dog make a drop outside, Ambudkar dropped some verses...More

Stephen Colbert Interviews Eminem on a Public Access Show
Stephen Colbert Interviews Eminem on a Public Access Show
2 July, 2015

Stephen Colbert's talk show hosting skills have been getting a little rusty since The Colbert Report ended in December. So the future Late Show host decided to take over Only in Monroe for the Monroe...More

'Suits' Renewed for Sixth Season at USA Network
'Suits' Renewed for Sixth Season at USA Network
2 July, 2015

Suits isn't going anywhere on USA Network.The Hollywood Reporter learned that the NBCUniversal-owned cable network has renewed the drama for a 16-episode sixth season,The series, produced by Universal...More